So here's the order and how I discovered this genre:
-Twilight series (Stephanie Meyer)
-House of Night series (P.C. Cast & Kristin Cast)
-Almost Human Trilogy (Melanie Nowak) <---story is lovely, the editing atrocious! I was willing to look past that for a great story.
-Sookie Stackhouse series
-Anita Blake series
-Duality: Guardians of the Light (Renee Wildes) <--- this was free on Kindle for a while. It was sweet, Goddess-based, but they used words like "betwixt" and "thee" and all that. I only read the first book when I learned the next was kind of related, but not a continuation at all. Each of the books stands alone.
-The Hollows series (just started the first book)
So based on my little reading adventure, here are my recommendations for you. :)
1. The Sookie Stackhouse series by Charlaine Harris has some wiccan characters, but this is not too prevalent. House of Night is kind of unique that way. This is the series that is now being made into the HBO TV show, True Blood. This will probably always be me favorite, even above the House of Night novels. The characters are memorable, the storytelling excellent, the plot progresses nicely (my main complaint about HoN is they don't advance the plot well... it's either too fast or too slow), and the whole series is just... well, charming. Granted I have yet to find another Goddess-worship-centric series like HoN, but these ones I'm suggesting still seem to fill some of the same void.
2. The Anita Blake series by Laurell Hamilton is great that way (it has many interesting themes relating to paganism and witchcraft, in a neutral-to-positive light), as it has elements, but that's not all that it's about. It can get gory and violent at times though, as the main character works with the police investigations "preternatural crime." But this series has "magick" prevalent throughout, and she lives in a world where Vampires are out of the closet, witches have unions, and magic of all sorts is a part of everyday life. The best part about these books is the characters. They are just wonderful, and I have grown to love them all.
3. Hamilton also has another series called Meredith Gentry, which is promising, but I don't know how it would compare to the House of Night series.
Meredith NicEssus is a faerie princess turned private investigator in a world where faeries are not only known to the general public, but are also fashionable. She takes on the pseudonym "Meredith Gentry" to hide from her family and her past while hiding out in Los Angeles, California as a private investigator at Grey's Detective Agency. Merry, the only Sidhe (pronounced "shee") royal to be born on American soil, fearing the continuous assassination attempts on her life thinly disguised as duels, flees the Unseelie Court in a final act of self-preservation. Her glamour (the art of magical disguise through illusion) is nearly unrivaled at court, and she is able to pass herself off as a human with fey blood.
The general tone of the writing is less of an outright fantasy and more of an alternate history. The point of divergence from normal history is not provided, although hints are given about how the faerie history intersects with human history (Adolf Hitler, the Irish Potato Famine, and Thomas Jefferson are examples). In the books, Jefferson gave the Unseelie and Seelie courts asylum after the European courts exiled them—however with the caveat that they could not set themselves up as gods or make war on one another, by doing so they would risk being evicted from US soil.
from wikipedia
4. Another series that I have looked at but not read yet (more than a few chapters) in is The Hollows series by Kim Harrison. (first book is called Dead Witch Walking...) It looks like there are currently 7 books in the series. THIS might be more of what you are looking for, maybe.
The Hollows series (also called the Rachel Morgan series) is a series of detective/mystery novels in an urban fantasy alternate historyKim Harrison that take place primarily in the city of Cincinnati. The city itself is mostly separated in two parts: The main part of the town (usually called downtown) and the enclave on the opposite side of the Ohio River nicknamed "The Hollows". Most Inderlanders setting by in Cincinnati live on "The Hollows", although exceptions exist on both sides.
There are five known branches of magic in the novels, earth magic, ley line magic, demonic magic, elven magic, and Celtic magic. All magic draws its power from ley lines, sources of energy that are scattered across the surface of the world. A magic user is labeled as either white or black, depending upon how the magic effects their soul. White magic is not damaging to the practitioner's soul, while black magic is. The stain upon the magic user's aura (energy emanated from the soul) depends on how much the magic distorts the natural. The stain, named because it appears as a black layer covering the aura, can by fostered off onto another but cannot be destroyed.
The series is set in an alternate history where supernatural beings live side-by-side with normal humans. According to this timeline, after the discovery of the DNA double-helix by James D. Watson, Francis Crick and Rosalind Franklin, genetic manipulation becomes a possibility, changing several events in the history of this alternate universe. A virus nicknamed the T4 Angel virus attached itself to a flaw in the genome of a genetically manipulated tomato (its lab identification being T4 Angel tomato), and quickly spread around the world. As a result of the plague, all biogenetic research, including reverse engineering and genetic splicing, has been outlawed.
from wikipedia
5. Finally, here is another author whose stuff gets recommended to me all the time on amazon. The wikipedia page about her makes it sound like her work might be promising in this department too...
Yasmine Galenorn writes urban fantasy/paranormal fiction. She is best known for her Otherworld Series featuring the D'Artigo Sisters. She has also written two mystery series and eight books on modern paganism, the most popular of which is Embracing the Moon. She is also working on a new series, Indigo Court, which will be published in 2010. The new series is not set within the same universe as the Otherworld Series. She will continue writing her current series in addition to the new series. Both mystery series are complete and no additional books are planned at this time. She has been active in the Craft since 1980[1] though she is not Wiccan[2]. Yasmine Galenorn previously wrote under the pen name India Ink for her Bath and Body series.
Sisters of the Moon
Chintz 'n China Mystery Series
Bath and Body Series (writing as India Ink)
Anthologies including Otherworld Series short stories
- Never After ISBN 9780515147285 (forthcoming October 27, 2009 US)
- Inked (forthcoming January 5, 2010 US)
Nonfiction Pagan titles